Don’t Buy That Book Meme: Lost in translation

A little before Christmas, Mig of eWritings tagged me with an interesting meme, one aimed at preventing people from wasting money on books that have no real value to offer them.

I’ve been lucky enough to have only bought books that either taught me something, or made me dream, or laugh, or think. I’ve never seen a book as a bad investment, unless I count some crappy text books. But those don’t count, as I didn’t exactly bought them because I really wanted to.

In order to complete the task, I thought of helping book lovers save money by offering advice that’s in the spirit of the meme, but doesn’t quite follow its guidelines to the letter. I hope Mig does not mind, as she means the world to me.

So here it goes: if you’re Romanian and want to buy a translated book but speak the language it was written it, don’t waste your money! Buy the original version through Amazon of whatever comes to mind and read it. It will save it quite some disappointment.

Bare in mind we’re not talking fiction here! Most of those books are a great read in Romanian as well. There are exceptions, but insignificant ones. When it comes to non-fiction, the saga begins! I’ve played with business, PR and marketing books that were translated from English and some fragments really scratched my soul and mind!

Besides, if you’re trying to learn things on you’re own, you might not get the essence of what’s said. For example, both publicity and advertising are translated as “publicitate” in Romanian. If you don’t know the difference and read a PR book, you might feel dizzy after the first 50 pages.

Yes, it might take longer to get the book. I doubt the book and the shipment will cost more than the original version. But at least you’ll get the author’s actual message.

Caveats

  • Advanced knowledge (or better yet proficiency) of said language is required
  • having the original boook won’t help if you’re trying to jump directly to doctorate level Maths but know squad about Maths to begin with.

Who to tag? If you ever bought a book and regreted it, consider yourself part of this meme!

Popularity: 7% [?]

This post has 9 comments

  • Sarah

    Oh this is really helpful however like yourself I have never bought a book and regretted it :) lucky us I presume

  • Alina Popescu

    Yes, lucky indeed! I love books a lot, but I would hate feeling I’ve wasted money on them.

  • Sarah

    OH lala I am loving the new picture Kay you look awesome :D

    Sarahs last blog post..NEW DISCOVERY

  • Beatrice

    I went through a similar phase, a self help book translated into Romanian, Dale Carnegie was the author but I forgot the title, lol. Like you said, it scratched my brain, ugh. The fiction ones are not that bad indeed. :)

  • Alex Cristache

    I totally agree. Whenever you have the option, read the book the way it was imagined and written by the author. Just like with movie subtitles, if you’re good with English, don’t waste a good movie with a poor subtitle.

    Alex Cristaches last blog post..10 Must-See Videos on WordPress.TV

  • Alina Popescu

    Yes, Trisi, I perfetly know how that feels! Some fiction translations are actually excellent!

    Alex, true again! There have been dozens of pages written about poor subtitles. But when the subtitle is good, it’s actually a pleasure analyzing it.

  • Mihaela Lica

    Aha! Well, although you don’t really specify what Romanian book is the culprit, you quality – coz it’s my contest and I do whatever I want with it. He he— I saw you run a contest too.

    Mihaela Licas last blog post..Magpie Threatens to Destroy Twitter

  • Alina Popescu

    That’s because it’s not only one book. There are several. The book in itself is not a waste of money, but the Romanian translation does make me wish I had bought the English version :)

    Yup, it’s kind of a bday party :)

Add a comment




CommentLuv Enabled

Additional comments powered by BackType